Compact mode

Erwin Smith vs Jean Kirstein vs Keith Shadis

Name: Erwin Smith
Brand: Erwin Smith
Rating: 8

Table of content

Powers and Abilities Comparison
Basic Information Comparison
Character Traits Comparison
Analysis Comparison
Facts Comparison

Military and Politics Comparison
Fan Reception Comparison
Usage Comparison
Origins Comparison
Performance Comparison

Powers and Abilities Comparison

Titan Shifter Status ⚡

Indicates whether character can transform into a Titan

For all*

No

Characters who have never possessed the ability to transform into titans and remain purely human throughout the series.
Overall Power Level 💪

Combined assessment of combat abilities and strategic importance

Erwin Smith

7

Combined assessment of combat abilities and strategic importance (30%) Most powerful characters possess exceptional abilities and overwhelming strength Click to see all.

Jean Kirstein

6

Combined assessment of combat abilities and strategic importance (30%) Most powerful characters possess exceptional abilities and overwhelming strength Click to see all.

Keith Shadis

5

Combined assessment of combat abilities and strategic importance (30%) Most powerful characters possess exceptional abilities and overwhelming strength Click to see all.
Titan Form Name 🗿

The specific name of the titan form if character possesses one

For all*

Not Applicable

Characters for whom titan transformation status is not relevant or applicable to their role in the story.
Character Strength Rating 💪

Subjective rating of character's overall strength and combat effectiveness

Erwin Smith

8

Subjective rating of character's overall strength and combat effectiveness (25%) Strongest characters possess exceptional physical power and combat abilities Click to see all.

Jean Kirstein

7

Subjective rating of character's overall strength and combat effectiveness (25%) Strongest characters possess exceptional physical power and combat abilities Click to see all.

Keith Shadis

5

Subjective rating of character's overall strength and combat effectiveness (25%) Strongest characters possess exceptional physical power and combat abilities Click to see all.
Combat Effectiveness Rating ⚡

A numerical rating representing the overall combat prowess and fighting ability of each character

Erwin Smith

8

A numerical rating representing the overall combat prowess and fighting ability of each character (25%) Characters with best combat effectiveness ratings are highly regarded for their fighting abilities Click to see all.

Jean Kirstein

7

A numerical rating representing the overall combat prowess and fighting ability of each character (25%) Characters with best combat effectiveness ratings are highly regarded for their fighting abilities Click to see all.

Keith Shadis

5

A numerical rating representing the overall combat prowess and fighting ability of each character (25%) Characters with best combat effectiveness ratings are highly regarded for their fighting abilities Click to see all.

Basic Information Comparison

Status ⚰️

Current living status of the character in the series

Erwin Smith

Deceased

The current status of Erwin Smith is Deceased Characters who have died during the course of the series due to battles, conflicts, or other circumstances. Click to see all.

Jean Kirstein

Alive

The current status of Jean Kirstein is Alive Characters who have survived the brutal conflicts and remain living throughout the series progression. Click to see all.

Keith Shadis

Deceased

The current status of Keith Shadis is Deceased Characters who have died during the course of the series due to battles, conflicts, or other circumstances. Click to see all.
Role in Story 🎭

The narrative significance and importance of each character within the Attack on Titan storyline

Erwin Smith

Main Character

The story role of Erwin Smith is Main Character Main characters drive the central narrative and undergo significant development throughout the series' progression. Click to see all.

Jean Kirstein

Supporting Character

The story role of Jean Kirstein is Supporting Character Characters who assist and interact with main characters while having their own smaller story arcs and development. Click to see all.

Keith Shadis

Supporting Character

The story role of Keith Shadis is Supporting Character Characters who assist and interact with main characters while having their own smaller story arcs and development. Click to see all.

Character Traits Comparison

Known For ⭐

Distinctive trait or achievement that defines the character

Erwin Smith

Survey Corps Commander

Erwin Smith is known for Survey Corps Commander.

Jean Kirstein

Pragmatic Leader

Jean Kirstein is known for Pragmatic Leader.

Keith Shadis

Former Survey Corps Commander

Keith Shadis is known for Former Survey Corps Commander.

Analysis Comparison

Pros ✅

Positive qualities and strengths of the character

Erwin Smith

Charismatic Leader

Strategic

Inspiring

Jean Kirstein

Realistic

Leader

Brave

Keith Shadis

Experienced Leader

Mentor Figure

Experienced Instructor

Sacrificial

Tough Instructor

Sacrifice
Cons ❌

Negative aspects and weaknesses of the character

Erwin Smith

Manipulative

Ruthless

Jean Kirstein

Cynical

Cynical characters often maintain realistic perspectives on harsh situations but may struggle with hope and positive team dynamics. Click to see all.

Argumentative

Keith Shadis

Harsh Methods

Self-Doubt

Facts Comparison

Interesting Fact 💡

Fascinating trivia or lesser-known information about the character

Erwin Smith

Sacrificed his arm and life for humanity

Jean Kirstein

Originally wanted to join Military Police for easy life

Keith Shadis

He trained most of the main characters
Sarcastic Fact 😏

Humorous or ironic observation about the character

Erwin Smith

Led suicide charges while asking soldiers to give up their dreams

Jean Kirstein

Goes from selfish coward to one of the most reliable soldiers

Keith Shadis

Realized he was ordinary and somehow made that inspiring